FDA Set to OK Cloned Meat and Milk

More Studies Needed to Ensure Public Safety, Science Group Says

January 9, 2008 -- The Food and Drug Administration is expected to declare as early as this week that meat and milk from cloned animals and their offspring pose no public health threat. The agency is likely to lift its "voluntary moratorium" on their sale.

Article continues below...

"FDA's announcement appears timed to avoid a provision in the Senate version of the farm bill requiring additional safety tests on cloned products before ending the moratorium," said Margaret Mellon, director of the Food and Environment Program at the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS). "The FDA should not try to subvert the will of Congress, which has wisely called for further studies to ensure there is no risk to public health."

Animal cloning is a controversial technology with few, if any, benefits to consumers, according to Mellon. Most cloned animals have severe defects and are more likely than ordinary farm animals to die at an early age. Although successful clones may appear normal, she said, the possibility remains that some may harbor subtle genetic defects that could impair their health or render them unsafe for consumption. She said the FDA should require that cloned products be labeled as such and keep them off the market at least until it establishes a mandatory tracking system to allow retailers to avoid purchasing the products.

FDA's draft risk assessment also failed to address ethical issues associated with cloning, including the role of animal cloning as a steppingstone to human cloning.

"The agency's draft risk assessment is long on assumptions and short on hard data," Mellon said. "We can afford the time needed to do additional studies."

Source: UCS